As your trusted local roofing company, Frye Roofing, serving Virginia and West Virginia, is often asked why we recommend architectural shingles over screw-down metal panels. Our commitment is to provide you with a durable, long-lasting solution, and our experience has shown that screw-down systems have inherent flaws. Here are four key reasons we stand behind modern architectural shingles. Contact us today.
Shingle vs. Screw-Down Metal Roofing

The Failure Point of Exposed Fasteners
The biggest weakness of a screw-down metal roof is the thousands of exposed fasteners used to hold it together. Each screw relies on a small rubber washer to seal out water. Over time, constant exposure to UV rays causes these washers to dry out, crack, and degrade. This process creates thousands of potential entry points for moisture, compromising your entire roof.

The Reality of Ongoing Maintenance
While some markets refer to screw-down metal as "low-maintenance," the reality is often the opposite. To prevent leaks from failing screw washers, these roofs require regular inspections and costly maintenance to tighten or replace fasteners. A properly installed shingle roof, by contrast, is a truly low-maintenance system that provides peace of mind for decades without the need for constant upkeep.

The Proven Performance of Shingles
Modern architectural shingles are engineered for outstanding durability and performance. Our professional roofing services include installing shingles that offer excellent resistance to wind, rain, and hail. They are installed with concealed fasteners, protecting the system’s most vulnerable points from the elements.

A Better Long-Term Investment
When you hire a roof installer, you are investing in your home’s protection. We believe architectural shingles offer a superior long-term value. They combine a lower upfront cost with proven longevity and minimal maintenance costs, avoiding the inherent design flaws of screw-down systems. As the best roofer and best local roofing company in the Virginia and West Virginia area, we only install systems we can stand behind.
CALL TODAY
When looking for the best roofing company in Virginia and West Virginia, choose one that prioritizes your home's future. Contact Frye Roofing today for a consultation on a roofing system built to last.